Rogue One Writer Thought Disney Would Reject Ending

Posted 2017/03/19480

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story took us back to the pivotal days before the opening of A New Hope, introducing us to the motley crew of rebels responsible for infiltrating the Empire and getting their hands on the precious plans that allowed Luke Skywalker and company to blow up the Death Star. And in very atypical fashion for a franchise like Star Wars and a studio like Disney, the movie ended with all further potential plans for that cast of new heroes being prematurely terminated when they were wiped out in the Battle of Scarif.

The deaths that brought Rogue One to a close helped that movie end on a poignant note (if you ignore the Darth Vader carnage that actually climaxed the film) and was overall met positively by audiences. However, there was a point when the movie’s writer believed this moving vision of sacrificial mass-death would never make it to the screen.

Rogue One screenwriter Gary Whitta told about the doubts he experienced when pitching the movie’s deadly ending to the brass at Disney:

“I never believed that they would let us kill off all the characters in the film. That was our original instinct. The very first meeting with Gareth I remember saying, ‘I kind of feel like they all need to die, but there’s no way Lucas … There’s no way Disney’ll let us do that. We can’t kill everybody. It’s a Disney movie.’ And yet, they were fully supportive of it, and it’s actually one of the coolest things about the film.”

Diego Luna as Cassian Andor Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso in Rogue One A Star Wars Story Rebel Alliance Rogue One Writer Thought Disney Would Reject Ending

Not only did killing off Jyn Erso, Cassian Andor, K-2SO, Chirrut Imwe, Bodhi Rook and Baze Malbus turn Rogue One into the kind of tragic bloodbath one does not necessarily associate with the Star Wars series, it also benefited the film’s standalone nature; Disney can’t bring those characters back for a sequel without undertaking some serious retconning (despite Felicity Jones having a contract option for such an eventuality). For a company as focused on maximizing assets as Disney, wiping out the cast of a potential new franchise in one fell swoop almost feels like a daring move.

On one hand, the tragic ending does help give the film a resonance which it otherwise may not have had, so as an artistic decision it’s a defensible one. On the other, one can’t help thinking about the possibilities that were lost when Jyn Erso and the gang met their untimely demises. It might have been cool to watch that cast come together again for another side-adventure set during a later major battle in the Star Wars universe.

It’s likely of course that Disney never had any intention of continuing the stories of the Rogue One cast after the standalone movie, regardless of the movie’s ultimate box office performance. As such, from the studio’s point-of-view, summarily annihilating all those characters was no big deal.